Measure of environmental accessibility (MEA): development and inter-rater reliability
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17411/jacces.v8i1.141Keywords:
accessibility, assessment, motor disabilities, visual disabilities, hearing disabilities, intellectual disabilities, cognitive disabilitiesAbstract
The Measure of accessibility to urban infrastructures for adults with physical disabilities was first published in 2012 and proved to have good inter-rater reliability. Yet, the format (more user-friendly) and content (updated references and labels) of this instrument needed to be improved. Therefore, a new version, now entitled Measure of Environmental Accessibility (MEA), was developed to provide professionals and individuals defending the rights of persons with disabilities with a more user-friendly, objective measure of accessibility of exterior and interior urban infrastructures for adults with mobility, visual and hearing impairments. The aim of this paper is to present the improvements made in this new version and evaluate its inter-rater reliability. This cross-sectional study for inter-rater reliability was conducted by a student in occupational therapy and a student in architecture who performed 30 MEA evaluations of public infrastructures. Inter-rater reliability was evaluated using Gwet’s AC1 statistic. Most items (71%, 626/882) had AC1 values ranging from good to excellent. Some items had lower inter-rater reliability coefficients (12%, 108/882, p-value <0.05) and a few had non-significant coefficients (6%, 52/882, p-value ≥0.05). These items are distributed unevenly in the MEA. Thus, it is impossible to predict which items are less appropriate. Another 96 items (11%) did not have a Gwet’s AC1 value since both raters did not observe the evaluated element. The MEA is a reliable accessibility measure for urban built environments. Its new content and format make it a useful tool for individuals involved in the design or renovation of the built environment to improve accessibility and, therefore, inclusion of individuals with disabilities.References
Absolu System. Guide pratique couleur & accessibilité (pp. 10). Rueil Malmaison, France: PPG AC France.
Adaptive Environmnets Center, & Barrier Free Environments. (1995). ADA accessibility checklist for existing facilities. Retrieved 2010-09-28, from www.ada.gov/racheck.pdf
ArgoServices. (2011). Fiches pratiques. Retrieved 2013/06/06, from http://www.argos-services.com/categorie/boite-a-outils/fiches-pratiques/
Arizona State University & Herberger Center for Design Excellence. (2005). The community survey. Liveable communities : an evaluation guide. Retrieved 2010-11-16, from assets.aarp.org/rgcenter/il/d18311_communities.pdf
Association des malentendants canadiens. (2008). Conception universelle et accès facile: lignes directrices pour les personnes malentendantes. from http://www.chha.ca/documents/Conception_universelle_et_acccs_facile.pdf
Bartfai, A., & Boman, I. (2011). Policies concerning assistive technology and home modification services for people with physical and cognitive disabilities in Sweden. Neuro Rehabilitation, 28, 303-308.
Bennett, S., Kirby, R. L., & Macdonald, B. (2009). Wheelchair accessibility: descriptive survey of curb ramps in an urban area. Disability and Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology, 4(1), 17-23.
Boyden, P., Esscopri, N., Ogi, L., Brennan, A., & Kalsy-Lillico, S. (2009). Service users leading the way: focus group methodology in developing accessible information DVDs with people with learning disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities, 13, 183.
Buchner, T. (2009). Deinstitutionalisation and community living for people with intellectual disabilities in Austria: history, policies, implementation and research. Tizard Learning Disability Review, 14(1), 4-13.
Canadian Heritage Parks Canada. (1994). Design guidelines for accessible outdoor recreation facilities.
Carey, A. C., Friedman, M. G., & Bryen, D. N. (2005). Use of electronic technologies by people with intellectual disabilities. Mental Retardation, 43, 322-333.
Casado, B. L., & Lee, S. E. (2012). Access barriers to and unmet needs for home and community based services among older korean americans. Home health care services quarterly, 31, 219-242.
CERTU. (2007). Une voirie accessible. juillet 2008. 2013, from http://www.certu.fr/IMG/pdf/Voirie-accessible_2008-06.pdf
CERTU, & CETE de Lyon. (2010). Zone de rencontre: Quels dispositifs repérables et détectables par les personnes aveugles et malvoyantes? : Centre d'Études sur les réseaux, les transports, l'urbanisme et les constructions publiques.
Christiaen, M. P. (2004). Vivre mieux dans un environnement visuel adapté. Genève: Association pour le Bien des Aveugles et malvoyants.
Clarke, P. J., Ailshire, J. A., Nieuwenhuijsen, E. R., & Vrankrijker, M. W. (2011). Participation among adults with disability: The role of the urban environment. Social Science & Medicine, 72(10), 1674-1684.
Comité régional du Tourisme Paris Ile-de-France - Maison de Victor Hugo. (2013). Accessibilité: Qualité de l'accueil à Paris Ile-de-France: Concevoir un guide adapté pour les personnes en situation de handicap mental (pp. 4).
Commission canadienne des droits de la personne [Canadian Human Rights Commission]. (2007). Pratiques exemplaires de conception universelle à l’échelle internationale : examen général [International best practices in universal design]. from www.chrc-ccdp.ca/pdf/bestpractices_fr.pdf
Confédération Française pour la Promotion Sociale des Aveugles et Amblyopes. (2010). Les besoins des personnes déficientes visuelles: Accès à la voirie et au cadre bâti. Retrieved from http://www.cfpsaa.fr/IMG/pdf/03_Recueil_besoins_DV_-_Voirie_et_Cadre_Bati_-_format_PDF.pdf.
Cooper, B. A., Cohen, U., & Hasselkus, B. R. (1991). Barrier-free design: a review and critique of the occupational therapy perspective. Am J Occup Ther, 45(4), 344-350.
CSA Group. (2012). Conception accessible pour l'environnement bâti (Vol. B651-12). Mississauga (ON): CSA Group.
Cunningham, G. O., Michael, Y. L., Farquhar, S. A., & Lapidus, J. (2005). Developing a reliable Senior Walking Environmental Assessment Tool. Am J Prev Med, 29(3), 215-217.
Davies, D. K., Stock, S. E., King, L. R., & Wehmeyer, M. L. (2008). ‘‘Moby-Dick is my favorite:’’ Evaluating a cognitively accessible portable reading system for audiobooks for individuals with intellectual disability. Intellectual and developmental disabilities, 46(4), 290-298.
Deliot-Lefevre, P. (2006). L'accessibilité des cadres bâtis, des lieux publics et des transports. Gérontologie et Société, 4(119), 11-23.
DeVellis, R. F. (2003). Scale development. Theory and applications (2nd edition ed. Vol. 26): Sage Publications.
Diamond, B. J., Shreve, G. M., Bonilla, J. M., Johnston, M. V., Morodan, J., & Branneck, R. (2003). Telerehabilitation, cognition and user-accessibility. NeuroRehabilitation, 18, 171-177.
Don MacDowall of Bass International Consulting for People Outdoors. (2004). Accessibility checklist – a self-assessment tool. Retrieved 2010-09-28, from http://www.qualitymall.org/products/prod1.asp?prodid=30481
Dos Santos, L. N., & de Carvalho, R. J. (2012). Ergonomics and accessibility for people with visual impairment in hotels. Work, 41 Suppl 1, 1417-1424.
Fédération française du bâtiment. (2009). Guide des bonnes pratiques de mise en couleur (pp. 16): FFB.
Felicetti, T. (2005). Barriers to Community Access: It’s About More Than Curb Cuts. Case manager, 226, 70-72.
Feliciano, L., Vore, J., Leblanc, L. A., & Baker, J. C. (2004). Decreasing entry intro a restricted area using a visual barrier. Journal of applied behavior analysis, 37(1), 107-110.
Fichten, C. S., Barile, M., Asuncion, J. V., & Fossey, M. E. (2000). What gouvernement, agencies and organizations can do to improve access to computers for postsecondary students with disabilities: recommendations based on Canadian empirical data. International journal of rehabilitation research (23), 191-199.
Ficocelli, M., & Nejat, G. (2012). The design of an interactive assistive kitchen system. Assistive technology: The official journal of RESNA, 24(4), 246-258.
Figoni, S. f., McClain, L., Bell, A. A., Degnan, J. M., Norbury, N. E., & Rettele, R. R. (1998). Accessibility of physical fitness facilities in the Kansas City metropolitan area. Rehabilitation, 3(3), 66-78.
Fortney, J., Chumbler, N., Cody, M., & Beck, C. (2002). Geographic access and service use in a community-based sample of cognitively impaired elders. The journal of applied gerontology, 21(3).
Fougeyrollas, P. (2010). La funambule, le fil et la toile. Transformations réciproques du sens du handicap: Les Presses de l'Université Laval.
Fox, L. E., Moore, M. S., Ficka, S., Lemoncello, R., & Prideaux, J. (2009). Public computing options for individuals with cognitive impairments: Survey outcomes. Disability and rehabilitation: Assistive technology, 4(5), 311-320.
Gamache, S., Vincent, C., Routhier, F., McFadyen, B. J., Beauregard, L., & Fiset, D. (2016a). Development of a measure of accessibility to urban infrastructures: a content validity study. Medical Research Archives, 4(5), 1-25.
Gamache, S., Vincent, C., Routhier, F., McFadyen, B. J., Beauregard, L., & Fiset, D. (2016b). Measure of accessibility to urban infrastructures for adults with physical disabilities (MAUAP): inter-rater reliability study. Medical Research Archives, 4(5), 1-14.
Garbutt, R. (2009). Is there a place within academic journals for articles presented in an accessible format? Disability & Society, 24(3), 357-371.
Giesbrecht, E. M., Ripat, J. D., Cooper, J. E., & Quanbury, A. O. (2011). Experiences with using a pushrim-activated power-assisted wheelchair for community-based occupations: a qualitative exploration. Canadian journal of occupational therapy, 78(2), 127-136.
Godsell, M., & Scarborough, K. (2006). Improving communication for people with learning disabilities. Nursing standard, 20(30), 58-65.
Greater Toronto Hotel Association. (2003). Greater Toronto hotel association hospitality checklist. Retrieved 2010-09-28, from http://www.gtha.com/GovernmentRelations/LegislativeUpdates/Accessibility/HospitalityCheckList.aspx
Hammel, J. (2003). Technology and the environment: supportive resource or barrier for people with developmental disabilities? Nursing Clinics of North America, 38(2), 331-349.
Hammel, J., Jones, R., Smith, J., Sanford, J., Bodine, C., & Johnson, M. (2008). Environmental barriers and supports to the health, function, and participation of people with developmental and intellectual disabilities: report from the State of the Science in Aging with Developmental Disabilities Conference. Disability and Health Journal, 1(3), 143-149.
Henderson, J., & Fuller, J. (2011). Problematising' Australian policy representations in responses to the physical health of people with mental health disorders. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 46(2), 183-203.
Hochhausen, L., Le, H.-N., & Perry, D. F. (2011). Community-based mental health service utilization among low-income latina immigrants. Community mental health journal, 47, 14-23.
Hornung, H. (2011). Towards a Design Rationale for Inclusive eGovernment Services. International Journal of Electronic Government Research, 7(3), 1-20.
ILSMH Association Européenne. (1998). Le savoir-simplifier: Directives européennes pour la Production d'Information en langage clair à l'usage des Personnes Handicapées Mentales. Retrieved 2013/07/30, from http://www.aqis-iqdi.qc.ca/f/nf154di/Le%20Savoir%20Simplifier.pdf
Institut Nazareth et Louis Braille, & Socitété Logique. (2003). Critères d'accessibilité répondant aux besoins des personnes ayant une déficience visuelle. from http://www.inlb.qc.ca/modules/pages/index.php?id=63&langue=fr
http://www.societelogique.org/contenu?page=actualites&nID=28
International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2011). Construction immobilière — Accessibilité et facilité d'utilisation de l'environnement bâti.
Jenkins, G. R., Yuen, H. K., & Vogtle, L. K. (2015). Experience of Multisensory Environments in Public Space among People with Visual Impairment. International journal of environmental research and public health, 12(8), 8644-8657.
Johnson, H., Douglas, J., Bigby, C., & Iacono, T. (2009). Maximizing community inclusion through mainstream communication services for adults with severe disabilities. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 11(3), 180-190.
Kelly, B., Sloan, D., Brown, S., Petrie, H., Lauke, P., Ball, S., et al. (2007). People, policies and processes. Accessibility 2.0, 7(8), 138-147.
Kelly, B., Sloan, D., Brown, S. C., Seale, J., Petrie, H., Lauke, P., et al. (2007). Accessibility 2.0: People, policies and processes. Paper presented at the 16th International World Wide Web Conference.
Kennedy, H., Evans, S., & Thomas, S. (2011). Can the web be made accessible for people with intellectual disabilities? The Information Society, 27, 29-39.
Kerr, J., & Rosenberg, D. E. (2009). Walking route audit tool for seniors [WRATS]. Retrieved 2010-12-15, from http://activelivingresearch.org/walking-route-audit-tool-seniors-wrats
Law, M. (1991). 1991 Muriel Driver lecture - The environment: a focus for occupational therapy. Canadian journal of occupational therapy, 58(4), 171-180.
Lubinsky, R. (2010). Communicating effectively with elders and their familities. ASHA Leader, 15, 12-15.
Luedtke, T., Goldammer, K., & Fox, C. (2012). Overcoming communication barriers: navigating client linguistic, literacy, and cultural differences. OT Practice, 17(4), 15-18.
Martins, L. B., & Gaudiot, D. M. (2012). The deaf and the classroom design: a contribution of the built environmental ergonomics for the accessibility. Work, 41 Suppl 1, 3663-3668.
McClain, L., Medrano, D., Marcum, M., & Schukar, J. (2000). A qualitative assessment of wheelchair users' experience with ADA compliance, physical barriers, and secondary health conditions. Topics in spinal cord injuriey rehabilitation, 6(1), 99-118.
McClain, L., & Todd, C. (1990). Food store accessibility. Am J Occup Ther, 44(6), 487-491.
Mcintyre, L. J., & Hanson, V. L. (2014). Buildings and users with visual impairment: Uncovering factors for accessibility using BIT-Kit. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 16th international ACM SIGACCESS conference on Computers & accessibility.
Measuring up program-2010 Legacies Now- Accessible Tourism Strategy. (2008). Non-accomodation checklist. Measuring up built environment self-assessment guidelines. Retrieved 2010-09-15, from file:///C:/Users/sgamache/Downloads/builtenvironment-self-assessment-guide.pdf
Millington, C., Ward Thompson, C., Rowe, D., Aspinall, P., Fitzsimons, C., Nelson, N., et al. (2009). Development of the Scottish Walkability Assessment Tool (SWAT). Health Place, 15(2), 474-481.
Ministère de l'écologie, d. d. e. d. l. a. d., Ministère du travail et des relations sociales et de la solidarité, & Ministère du logement et de la ville. (2008). Circulaire interministérielle no 2007-53 DGUHC du 30 novembre 2007 relative à l’accessibilité des établissements recevant du public, des installations ouvertes au public et des bâtiments d’habitation. Retrieved 2013/07/20, from http://www2.equipement.gouv.fr/bulletinofficiel/fiches/bo200723/a0230052.htm
Ministère des Transports de l'écologie du Toursime et de la Mer. (2012). Prescriptions techniques pour l'accessibilité de la voirie et des espaces publics. from http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do;jsessionid=2063DE928ED2B87A26719E370FA8D462.tpdjo14v_3?cidTexte=LEGITEXT000006055384&dateTexte=20130720
Namazi, K. H., Rosner, T. T., & Calkins, M. P. (1989). Visual barriers to prevent ambulatory alzheimer's patients from exiting through an emergency door. Gerontologist, 29(5), 699-702.
Nind, M., & Seale, J. (2009). Concepts of access for people with learning difficulties: towards a shared understanding. Disability & Society, 24(3), 273-287.
O'Regan, P., & Drummond, E. (2008). Cancer information needs of people with intellectual disability: a review of literature. European journal on oncology nursing, 12, 142-147.
ONIP, FAF, & Argos-Service. (2011). Contrastes & Harmonies (pp. 6).
OPHQ. (2009). À part entière : pour un véritable exercice du droit à l’égalité », Politique gouvernementale pour accroître la participation sociale des personnes handicapées. Retrieved from http://www.ophq.gouv.qc.ca/fileadmin/documents/Politique_a_part_entiere_Acc.pdf
Pôle ressources national sport et handicap. (2012). Accessibilité des équipements, espaces, sites et itinéraires sportifs: Les gymnases: Guide d'usage conception et aménagements. Bourges, France: Pôle ressources national sport et handicap.
Poncelas, A., & Murphy, G. (2007). Accessible information for people with intellectual disabilities: Do symbols really help? Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 20, 466-476.
Porter, Z. (2005). FOREWORD. British Journal of Learning Disabilities, 33, 47.
Price, J. D., Hermans, D., & Evans, J. G. (2009). Subjective barriers to prevent wandering of cognitively impaired people (Review). The Cochrane Collaboration, 1-12.
Reagan, S. L. (2004). Perceived Mental and Physical Health: How Is It Influenced by Demographics, Health Behaviors, and Access to Health Care Resources? Dissertation Abstracts International: The Humanities and Social Sciences, 64(12).
Research Alliance for Children with Special Needs. (2003). Physical accessibility measure for schools (PAMS). In L. Klinger (Ed.) (pp. paper 5): Occupational Therapy Publications.
Research Alliance for Children with Special Needs and the School of occupational therapy & the University of Western Ontario. (2010). University campus accessibility measure (UCAM) (pp. paper 6): Occupational Therapy Publications.
Rochette, A., & Loiselle, F. (2012). Successfully performing a university student’s role despite disabilities: challenges of an inclusive environment and appropriate task modification. Disability & Rehabilitation, 34(25), 2201–2206.
Rosenberg, D. E., Huang, D. L., Simonovich, S. D., & Belza, B. (2013). Outdoor built environment barriers and facilitators to activity among midlife and older adults with mobility disabilities. Gerontologist, 53(2), 268-279.
Rosenberg, L., Ratzon, N. Z., Jarus, T., & Bart, O. (2010). Development and initial validation of the environmental restriction questionnaire. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 31, 1323–1331.
Service de l’aménagement du territoire de la Ville de Québec. (2010). Guide pratique d’accessibilité universelle [Quebec City's Practical guide to universal accessibility]. from http://www.irdpq.qc.ca/nos-services/accessibilite-universelle/guide-pratique-daccessibilite-universelle
Shumway-Cook, A., Patla, A., Stewart, A. L., Ferrucci, L., Ciol, M. A., & Guralnik, J. M. (2005). Assessing environmentally determined mobility disability: self-report versus observed community mobility. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 53(4), 700-704.
Solway, E., Estes, C. L., Goldberg, S., & Berry, J. (2010). Access barriers to mental health services for older adults from diverse populations: perspectives of leaders in mental health and aging. Journal of aging & social policy, 22, 360-378.
Spandler, H. (2007). From social exclusion to inclusion? A critique of the inclusion imperative in mental health. Medical Sociology Online, 2(2), 3.
Stark, S., Hollingsworth, H. H., Morgan, K. A., & Gray, D. B. (2007). Development of a measure of receptivity of the physical environment. Disabil Rehabil, 29(2), 123-137.
Steinfeld, E., & Maisel, J. L. (2012). Universal design: Creating inclusive environments. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Stock, S. E., Davies, D. K., Wehmeyer, M. L., & Lachapelle, Y. (2011). Emerging new practices in technology to support independent community access for people with intellectual and cognitive disabilities. NeuroRehabilitation, 28, 261–269.
Swedberg, L. (2001). Facilitating accessibility and participation in faith communities. OT Practice, 6(9), 1-8.
Thapar, N., Warner, G., Drainoni, M. L., Williams, S. R., Ditchfield, H., Wierbicky, J., et al. (2004). A pilot study of functional access to public buildings and facilities for persons with impairments. Disabil Rehabil, 26(5), 280-289.
Thorpe, J. M., Houtven, C. H. V., & Sleath, B. L. (2009). Barriers to outpatient care in community-dwelling elderly with dementia : The role of caregiver life satisfaction. Journal of applied gerontology, 4, 436-460.
Todis, B., Sohlberg, M. M., Hood, D., & Fickas, S. (2005). Making electronic mail accessible: Perspectives of people with acquired cognitive impairments, caregivers and professionals. Brain Injury, 19(6), 389–401.
Torres, J. E., & Berg, S. V. (2008). Effects of two applications on the success of E-mail access for an individual with acquired cognitive impairment [dissertation]. Reno (NV): University of Nevada.
Townsley, R., Rodgers, J., & Folkes, L. (2003). Getting informed: Researching the production of accessible information for people with learning disabilities. Journal of Integrated Care, 11(3), 39-43.
Transports Québec. (2007). Normes de la construction routière MTQ – Normes [Construction norms of Quebec's ministry of Transport]. Retrieved 2011/10/05, from http://www3.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/produits/ouvrage_routier/normes/norme7.en.html
Tranter, R. T., Slater, R., & Vaughan, N. (1991). Barriers to mobility: physically-disabled and frail elderly people in their local outdoor environment. International journal of rehabilitation research, 14(4), 303-312.
U.S. Department of Justice. (2001). ADA checklist for new lodging facilities. Retrieved 2010-09-28, from www.ada.gov/hsurvey.htm#anchor96917
U.S. Department of Justice. (2004). ADA checklist for polling places. Retrieved 2010-09-28, from www.ada.gov/votingck.htm
UNAPEI. (2009). Guide pratique de l'accessibilité: Pour vous accompagner dans vos démarches en matière d'accessibilité en faveur des personnes en situation de handicap mental (pp. 39). Paris, France: UNAPEI.
UNAPEI. (2012). Guide pratique de la signalétique et des pictogrammes (pp. 60). Paris, France: UNAPEI.
Verdonschot, M. M. L., Witte, L. P. d., Reichrath, E., Buntinx, W. H. E., & Curfs, L. M. G. (2009). Impact of environmental factors on community participation of persons with an intellectual disability: a systematic review. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 53(1), 54-64.
Vilar, E., Filgueiras, E., & Rebelo, F. (2007). Integration of people with disabilities in the workplace: A methodology to evaluate the accessibility degree. Occupational ergonomics, 7, 94-114.
Walsh, J., Scaife, V., Caitlin, N., Dodsworth, J., & Schofield, G. (2011). Perception of need and barriers to access: the mental health needs of young people attending a Youth Offending Team in the UK. Health and Social Care in the Community, 19(4), 420-428.
Wennberg, B., & Kjellberg, A. (2010). Participation when using cognitive assistive devices from the perspective of people with intellectual disabilities. Occupational therapist, 17, 168-176.
Williams, P., & Nicholas, D. (2006). Testing the usability of information technology applications with learners with special educational needs. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 6(1), 31-41.
Wongpakaran, N., Wongpakaran, T., Wedding, D., & Gwet, K. L. (2013). A comparison of Cohen's Kappa and Gwet's AC1 when calculating inter-rater reliability coefficients: a study conducted with personality disorder samples. BMC Medical research methodology, 13, 61.
World Health Organization, & The World Bank. (2011). World report on disability. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/disabilities/world_report/2011/en/.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share or adapt the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal. Use of the work for commercial purposes are not allowed.
- Authors are able to publish the journal's published version of the work in other media (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), as far as they inform the Journal of Accessibility and Design for All of that fact. When publishing their work in other sources, authors must mention the name of the Journal of Accessibility and Design for All, its ISSN, the number and issue in which the article was published and a link to the main page of the Journal of Accessibility and Design for All. Optionally, they can also include a link to the article published in the Journal of Accessibility and Design for All.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website), as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
